Review · EDINBURGH

The Mountebank Comedy Walk of Edinburgh

★ 5.0 · 1,813 reviews 2 hours (approx.) From $36 Bookable on Viator
Book on Viator →

Edinburgh’s Old Town has plenty of serious history, but Daniel Downie tells it with a comic edge, a kilt, and a willingness to make you part of the joke. You’ll walk from Monkey Barrel Comedy along the Royal Mile, past St Giles’ Cathedral and Edinburgh Castle, then finish among the graves and legends of Greyfriars.

I like two things here: the history is delivered by a working comedian with a master’s degree in Scottish history, and the route covers several major Old Town sights without turning into a dry lecture. I also like the personal start, where Daniel learns your names and teaches Scottish vocabulary. The drawback is clear: this is adult comedy, and anyone with a delicate ego may prefer a quieter, more traditional tour.

Key points to know before you book

The Mountebank Comedy Walk of Edinburgh - Key points to know before you book

  • Daniel Downie leads the walk: He is a Scots comedian, historian, and an energetic guide who wears a kilt.
  • Braan the dog comes along: Daniel’s friendly dog adds a warm, informal touch to the tour.
  • The route covers famous Old Town sights: You’ll see the Royal Mile, Mercat Cross, St Giles’ Cathedral, Edinburgh Castle, Grassmarket, and Greyfriars.
  • Expect audience participation: Daniel learns about the group and may turn jobs, nationalities, sports teams, or personal details into jokes.
  • The comedy is adult and irreverent: The humor includes colorful language, dark stories, and teasing aimed at everyone.
  • Bring sensible shoes and warm layers: The route includes hills, steps, and exposed streets, and the walk runs for about two hours.

Why this tour works as an Edinburgh introduction

The Mountebank Comedy Walk of Edinburgh - Why this tour works as an Edinburgh introduction

The Mountebank Comedy Walk does not try to be a full survey of Scotland. In two hours, you get a lively introduction to Edinburgh’s Old Town, with enough history to help you understand the streets around you and enough jokes to make the facts stick.

That mix matters. You might forget the exact date of a royal proclamation, but you are more likely to remember it when it comes wrapped in a story about punishment, treachery, or an outrageous local character. Daniel’s background gives the walk more substance than a string of one-liners, while his comedy keeps the pace moving.

The group can include up to 20 people, which is small enough for direct conversation but large enough for Daniel to find plenty of comic material. He makes a point of learning who you are at the beginning. That personal approach shapes the rest of the walk, since you may become part of a joke rather than simply standing in a crowd listening to a speech.

This is not the right choice if you want a quiet architectural tour or a detailed visit inside every building. Most stops are viewed from outside, and the purpose is to connect places with stories rather than provide long examinations of art, design, or religious practice.

More walking tours around Edinburgh:

Starting at Monkey Barrel Comedy

The Mountebank Comedy Walk of Edinburgh - Starting at Monkey Barrel Comedy

The tour begins outside Monkey Barrel Comedy at 9 to 12 Blair Street. This is a useful starting point because you meet at a comedy club rather than a generic street corner. Daniel first asks a little about you, shares some information about himself, and teaches a few favorite Scottish words before setting off.

That opening helps break the ice. You are not expected to remain anonymous in the back of the group. The comedy depends partly on this exchange, so it is worth arriving ready to take part.

Admission to the comedy club is not included, and this walk is separate from seeing a stand-up show there. The meeting point is close to Edinburgh’s Old Town and public transport, though the route itself is entirely on foot.

Daniel wears a kilt, which gives the beginning a clear Scottish character without needing any grand introduction. He is also joined by his dog Braan, a detail that has become an important part of the experience. The dog offers a softer counterpoint to the darker tales and gives you a chance to stop for a quick pat along the way.

The Royal Mile and Mercat Cross

The first major section takes you onto the Royal Mile, Edinburgh’s best-known historic street. You spend about ten minutes here, so do not expect a full tour of every close, shop, and building. Instead, Daniel uses the street as a setting for the city’s past and its crowded public life.

The Royal Mile is easy to recognize, but it can be hard to understand without context. Daniel’s commentary helps connect the pavement beneath you with the older city that once held markets, proclamations, punishments, and daily trade in the same busy space.

At Mercat Cross, the focus turns to medieval commerce and public announcements. This was a place where trade took place, but it also served as a stage for royal proclamations and punishments. That combination says much about old Edinburgh, where business, politics, and public justice could all happen within the same few yards.

The stop lasts about ten minutes and does not include an admission ticket. The value is in the story rather than entry to a museum. Listen for the way Daniel turns a fixed monument into a picture of a city that could be noisy, harsh, and highly public.

St Giles’ Cathedral and Edinburgh’s religious past

The Mountebank Comedy Walk of Edinburgh - St Giles’ Cathedral and Edinburgh’s religious past

St Giles’ Cathedral is described as the most significant religious site in the Old Town, and the tour uses it to explain Edinburgh’s role in the Reformation. You stop outside for around ten minutes, so this is an orientation point rather than an interior visit.

The building is also tied to military and political characters, including the Great Montrose, a swashbuckling figure whose resting place is connected with the cathedral. Daniel’s style suits this material. The stories here are not only about theology. They are also about power, loyalty, conflict, and personalities that sound almost too dramatic to be real.

If you want to study the cathedral’s interior, monuments, or architecture, plan a separate visit. The walking tour gives you a useful reason to look more closely, but it does not replace a proper cathedral stop.

Same streets, a different story:

Writers, books, and the city’s literary characters

The Mountebank Comedy Walk of Edinburgh - Writers, books, and the city’s literary characters

Outside the Writers’ Museum, Daniel offers a comic treatment of some of Edinburgh’s best-known literary figures. The museum itself is not included, and the stop lasts about ten minutes.

This is one of the more distinctive parts of the route because it broadens the story beyond kings, battles, and criminals. Edinburgh’s identity is tied to writers and poets as much as to castles and executions. Daniel’s approach is not a formal literary lecture. He uses the personalities and reputations of famous figures as material for jokes, comparisons, and quick historical detail.

The short format works well if you want an overview. It may feel too brief if you are especially interested in Scottish literature or plan to visit the museum. Think of it as a lively introduction that can help you decide which writers deserve more of your time later.

Edinburgh Castle from the south side

The Mountebank Comedy Walk of Edinburgh - Edinburgh Castle from the south side

The castle stop gives you a panorama of Edinburgh Castle from the south side, rather than admission to the fortress itself. You spend about ten minutes here, hearing about Sir Thomas Randolph’s daring raid in March 1314.

The view is one of the practical strengths of the route. Edinburgh Castle is famous, but a good angle can change how you see it. From below, the rock and walls make sense as a defensive position, and the story of Randolph’s raid gives the monument more meaning than a quick photograph alone.

Your ticket does not include entry to Edinburgh Castle. If the castle is high on your list, book a separate visit and allow much more time. This tour gives you a strong outside view and one memorable historical episode, but it is not a substitute for exploring the castle grounds and exhibitions.

Grassmarket, crime, and public punishment

The Mountebank Comedy Walk of Edinburgh - Grassmarket, crime, and public punishment

Grassmarket brings the walk into Edinburgh’s darker past. It was a market area, but it was also linked with law, disorder, and public executions. Daniel treats this material with the grim humor that suits the city’s old tales.

The stop lasts around ten minutes. You may hear about the way justice was displayed in public and how the area became associated with crime and punishment. This is not sanitized history, so you should expect stories that can be gruesome.

The modern Grassmarket is a lively place to eat and drink, which makes the contrast especially sharp. The tour helps you see beyond the current shops and restaurants to the harsher role the area once played. It also gives you a useful landmark for returning later, perhaps when you want lunch or an evening meal.

Greyfriars, bodysnatchers, ghosts, and a famous dog

The Mountebank Comedy Walk of Edinburgh - Greyfriars, bodysnatchers, ghosts, and a famous dog

The final stop is Greyfriars Kirkyard, where the tour brings together several of Edinburgh’s most familiar legends. You hear about the graveyard’s religious and historical importance, the city’s bodysnatchers, ghost stories, Harry Potter connections, and Greyfriars Bobby.

The stop lasts about 15 minutes, making it one of the longer pauses on the route. That extra time helps because Greyfriars can feel crowded with stories. Daniel gives the place a comic frame, but the setting itself carries much of the mood.

Greyfriars Bobby is an especially fitting subject with Braan accompanying the group. The dog adds a personal touch to the story and often becomes part of the group’s enjoyment. You should not expect an extended visit to every famous grave or a detailed guide to all the Harry Potter connections. The point is to finish with a selection of the kirkyard’s best-known tales.

The stated end point is Greyfriars Kirkyard, though the exact route can change and the finish may vary within the Old Town. That is not a major problem, since you remain in a central area with plenty of onward options.

What the comedy is really like

Daniel’s humor is direct, personal, and sometimes crude. He may tease people about their jobs, nationalities, sports teams, or other details shared at the start. The aim is to include the group, but you should be comfortable with being noticed.

The jokes are not limited to the local audience. English visitors, international visitors, and Scots can all expect some attention. No one is completely exempt, which keeps the group alert and helps strangers relax around one another.

This approach works best when you enjoy live comedy and do not mind playful embarrassment. If you prefer to listen quietly or dislike colorful language, choose a conventional history walk instead. The tour is strictly for ages 16 and over, and the humor is clearly aimed at adults.

The strongest feature is the balance between jokes and substance. Daniel does not simply riff from one landmark to the next. His academic background in Scottish history gives the stories structure, and the comedy gives you a reason to remember them.

Walking conditions, timing, and weather

The tour lasts about two hours and includes Old Town hills and steps. You do not need to be an athlete, since most stops are short, but wear shoes that feel secure on uneven streets. The route is not a seated experience, and you may be standing while Daniel speaks.

Edinburgh weather can change quickly. Some accounts of the walk describe wet and windy conditions made enjoyable by Daniel’s energy, but the booking terms also state that the experience requires good weather and may be canceled if conditions are poor. Bring a waterproof layer and dress warmly, especially in winter.

The tour is offered in English. Service animals are allowed, and most people can take part, but anyone concerned about walking, steps, or standing should consider those demands before booking.

Is $36.06 a fair price?

At $36.06 per person, this costs more than a basic free walking tour tip, but the comparison is not exact. You are paying for a named comedian who also has formal training in Scottish history, a small maximum group of 20, and a two-hour route built around performance as well as sightseeing.

I see the value most clearly if you want a strong first look at the Old Town and enjoy live comedy. You cover several major places without paying separate entrance fees, though the price does not include entry to the castle, cathedral, Writers’ Museum, or Monkey Barrel Comedy.

The tour also works well as a first-day activity. It gives you a mental map of the Royal Mile, Grassmarket, Greyfriars, and the castle viewpoint. You can then return to the places that caught your interest and spend more time inside them.

The value is weaker if your main goal is detailed academic history, long interior visits, or a slow photography walk. Much of the experience depends on Daniel’s personality, and the humor is a central part of what you are buying.

Who should book the Mountebank Comedy Walk?

I would choose this tour if you want history delivered with a live comic rhythm, like meeting the guide as a person, and enjoy a little audience participation. It suits couples, friends, solo visitors who like joining a group, and adults planning a first look at Edinburgh’s Old Town.

It also fits a celebration or group outing, including a stag event, provided everyone is comfortable with adult jokes and public teasing. The dog is a bonus for anyone who enjoys animals, though Braan is part of the walk rather than the main attraction.

I would choose something else if you want a calm, formal account of Edinburgh, if you need a child-friendly tour, or if being singled out would spoil the day. The walk is friendly, but it is not timid.

Cancellation and booking details

You receive confirmation when you book, and free cancellation is available up to 24 hours before the start time for a full refund. Cancellations or changes made within 24 hours are not refunded or accepted.

The tour requires a minimum number of people. If that minimum is not reached, you are offered another date or experience, or a full refund. Weather can also affect the schedule, so keep your plans flexible if conditions look poor.

Should you book it?

Book the Mountebank Comedy Walk if you want to laugh while learning why Edinburgh’s Old Town is full of kings, writers, criminals, ghosts, executions, and unforgettable dogs. Daniel Downie brings real historical background, but he does not make you work through a formal lecture.

The best reason to choose it is the combination of personal comedy, Scottish storytelling, and a well-chosen Old Town route. Just bring warm clothing, good walking shoes, and a willingness to become part of the joke. If that sounds like fun, the $36.06 price is a fair way to get your bearings and enjoy Edinburgh with Daniel and Braan.

FAQ

How long does the Mountebank Comedy Walk last?

The walk lasts approximately two hours.

Where does the tour begin?

It begins at Monkey Barrel Comedy, 9 to 12 Blair Street, Edinburgh EH1 1QR.

Where does the tour finish?

It usually finishes at Greyfriars Kirkyard on Greyfriars Place. The route and exact finishing point can change, but the end remains in Edinburgh’s Old Town.

Is Edinburgh Castle admission included?

No. The tour stops for a view of Edinburgh Castle from the south side and discusses Sir Thomas Randolph’s raid, but castle admission is not included.

Is the tour suitable for children?

No. The experience is strictly for ages 16 and over, and the comedy includes adult humor.

What happens if I need to cancel?

You can cancel at least 24 hours before the start time for a full refund. Cancellations within 24 hours are not refunded. If the tour is canceled because of poor weather or because the minimum number of people is not met, you are offered another date or experience, or a full refund.

Same streets, other guides

Edinburgh Walking Tours, side by side.

The whole list: Edinburgh Walking Tours →
Edinburgh: Harry Potter Magical Guided Walking Tour
★★★★★★★★★★4.8· 11,944 reviews· from $19

Edinburgh: Harry Potter Magical Guided Walking Tour

Read our review →
Edinburgh Castle: Guided Walking Tour with Entry Ticket
★★★★★★★★★★4.7· 11,699 reviews· from $49

Edinburgh Castle: Guided Walking Tour with Entry Ticket

Read our review →
Underground Vaults Walking Tour in Edinburgh Old Town
★★★★★★★★★★4.5· 8,506 reviews· from $33

Underground Vaults Walking Tour in Edinburgh Old Town

Read our review →
Edinburgh Castle Guided Walking Tour in English
★★★★★★★★★★5.0· 5,214 reviews· from $52

Edinburgh Castle Guided Walking Tour in English

Read our review →
Edinburgh Darkside Walking Tour: Mysteries, Murder and Legends
★★★★★★★★★★5.0· 3,862 reviews· from $29

Edinburgh Darkside Walking Tour: Mysteries, Murder and Legends

Read our review →
Edinburgh: Old Town History and Tales Walking Tour
★★★★★★★★★★4.8· 2,361 reviews· from $24

Edinburgh: Old Town History and Tales Walking Tour

Read our review →
Haunted Vaults Walking Tour in Edinburgh
★★★★★★★★★★5.0· 2,183 reviews· from $33

Haunted Vaults Walking Tour in Edinburgh

Read our review →
Edinburgh: Dark Secrets of the Old Town Ghost Walking Tour
★★★★★★★★★★4.6· 1,671 reviews· from $24

Edinburgh: Dark Secrets of the Old Town Ghost Walking Tour

Read our review →
Scroll to Top

Explore on foot

Pick a theme, a time of day, or a city.